- Cathedral Ward:
- Bloodshot Eyeball x1, left path from Grand Cathedral on way to Hemwick.
- Hemwick Charnel Lane:
- Bloodshot Eyeball x1, left side of the Village Square.
- Bloodshot Eyeball x1, In the stables on floor 2.
- Obtained after defeating The Witch of Hemwick.
- Rare drop from Eye Collectors.
- Chalice Dungeons.
- Purchased from the Insight Bath Messengers for 2 Insight after killing The Witch of Hemwick.